MINUTES
USA
BOXING BOARD OF DIRECTORS (“BOD”)
REGULAR MEETING
March 10, 2007
Doubletree Hotel San Antonio
International Airport
San Antonio, Texas
I.
Roll Call
Board Members Present:
James Beasley, Angel Bovee, Thomas
Coulter, Boyd Melson,David Swavey, Thomas Virgets, Kevin Franklin
Board Members by Phone: Alan
Rothenberg 9 a.m., Robert Blaha
joined at 10 a.m. until 11 a.m.
Board Members Absent: Andy
Geiger
Staff Present:
John Stavros,
Interim Executive Director (ED), Linda Gleeson, Business Manager; Debra Ketner,
Executive Assistant; and National
Coach, Dan Campbell
Guests:
Chris Vadala, Senior Director Sports
Partnership; Ronald Simms, Marine
Coach; Joe Malik, Global1NBC
Guests by Phone:
USOC CEO,
Jim Scherr, joined
at 11 a.m. Central time.
II.
Approval of the Minutes of the Board
of Directors
A.
MOTION/SECONDED/CARRIED (Beasley)
to approve the minutes of December
18, 2006 from
Los Angeles,
CA
III.
Chairman’s Opening Remarks
USA Boxing Board Chairman, Tom Virgets
stated Chris Vadala, USOC
representative, would be joining the
meeting later in the morning. Vadala is
responsible for Sports Partnerships.
Jim Scherr, President of the USOC, will
also be joining by conference call at 11
a.m. Central time.
Virgets reported the USOC had made an
offer to USAB for additional support.
Virgets stated that the Board should be
apprised of that offer, and also
understand how the office of Sports
Partnership functions. It is the
Board’s desire to improve the
partnership between the USOC and USA
Boxing. The USOC has approved this new
group of Trustees, and they ask for the
strong support of the USOC going
forward. Virgets stated that the Board
wants the USOC to do whatever is
necessary to make this a true sports
partnership. Virgets stated his belief
that there needs to be improved mutual
support, and a closer working
relationship which complements the
financial support provided annually to
USA Boxing as part of the High
Performance Plan.
A. The Vision for
USA Boxing (enclosed)
Virgets stated that USAB’s membership
expects the national office, and the
Board to keep the membership better
informed. Virgets stated we must become
more transparent. With that Tom Coulter
asked what specifically can and cannot
be discussed with the membership.
Virgets stated that Executive Session
must be reserved for the Board to
legally discuss sensitive issues. Boyd
Melson stated that if it is communicated
to the LBCs that membership has the
option to go on the website under “Ask
the Board” to ask questions, this would
help the situation. Virgets expressed
that there also needs to be a monthly
update to the membership from the
Executive Director.
IV. USOC Update
John Stavros,
Acting Executive Director, (AED)
reported that the USOC has made a
financial offer of additional support to
USA Boxing and USAB has been requesting
the offer in writing for several weeks.
The offer includes support toward the $1
million liability insurance and funding
for broadcast rights to USA Boxing
Events. After further discussion by
Stavros regarding a vision for
television, Stavros received Board
support to further define television
rights. The USOC had also previously
required USAB to seek USOC approval for
the USAB ED position; they are now
asking for input in the search. The
USOC also agreed to review the issue of
prior payments owed to the USOC by USAB.
Virgets stated the issue is what does
USAB need from the USOC? Virgets
expressed the opinion that USAB needs a
better understanding of the Sports
Partnerships relationship and role.
Virgets also asked if this partnership
was not working was there a way to hold
USAB’s Sports Partnership accountable,
as the USOC holds USAB accountable?
MOTION/SECONDED/CARRIED (Swavey)
Virgets to coordinate bringing these
issues to the attention of USOC
leadership.
A.
USOC Offer
Chris Vadala joined the meeting in
person, and
Jim Scherr joined the
meeting by conference call. Virgets
stated that USAB is in receipt of and
appreciates USOC’s offer.
Virgets also asked for the definition of
a Sports Partner. Scherr stated that
the Sports Partnership Director is the
NGB’s primary communication vehicle and
liaison to the United States Olympic
Committee (USOC). The Sports
Partnership Program is designed to be
the primary delivery vehicle for the
resources that the USOC provides to the
National Governing Body (NGB) and the
principle process for resource
allocation. The NGB submits their High
Performance Plan, which is evaluated on
certain conditions in the Performance
Partnership Agreement. The Sports
Partner transfers resources and monitors
the performance of those conditions.
Vadala stated that in addition to the
resource allocation, their role is to
assist the NGB with all the different
facets of relationship with the USOC.
Virgets stated that prior to the seating
of the present Board that USAB had many
issues and problems with this
relationship. It was his belief the
ongoing probation, monitoring, and
policing of the present Boards actions
are unwarranted. Scherr stated that
management of the unilateral
re-allocation of the dollars, or
resources provided by the USOC without a
High Performance Plan was and still is
one of the reasons that USAB was and
still is on probation. Virgets also
expressed a concern pertaining to the
USOC audit. It’s his understanding that
in the past, re-allocation of dollars
was allowed for under and over budgeted
projects as long as the programs were
previously approved.
Scherr stated he did not know if there
had ever been anytime in the past, or in
the last seven years in the current
resource allocation process, that an NGB
had been allowed to unilaterally
re-allocate dollars. There would have to
be a specific written agreement, and
evidence of the USOC’s approval to
transfer dollars to another purpose for
the auditors to rely upon that
information. Scherr stated he was not
aware that there was an agreement in
writing, or otherwise, between USAB and
the USOC that would have allowed for a
re-allocation of dollars. However,
Scherr remained committed to review the
situation as the organization is trying
to establish itself and move forward. Scherr
also stated that the USOC would review a
written justification from USAB as to
why those dollars should be reallocated,
and stated that the USOC was not trying
to tie the current Board with debt;
however, the USOC has a fiduciary
responsibility to their Board, and to
their organization that if funds are
approved to be expended in a specific
way that they are expended in that way.
The USOC has to justify these audit
reports to their Board, their Auditors,
and they have a fiduciary responsibility
to their organization, a very specific
legal one.
Virgets stated that USAB’s biggest
concern at this point is the
communication that is taking place
between our Sports Partner, this Board
and USAB’s Executive Director. Scherr
also stated that the USOC wants to be
viewed by USAB’s Board as a partner, and
that the USOC would not have made the
offer of support if they did not want to
be a partner with USAB.
Scherr asked if there is any part of the
offer that Vadala has transmitted to
USAB on his behalf that USAB would like
clarification on. Virgets stated that
USAB would like to see the television
contract, and exactly what that
entails. The Board would also like
clarification as to whether this offer
is an all-or-none package. Scherr asked
that USAB address the USOC with its
questions, and then the USOC can
respond. Vadala insisted that
communications will improve, and that he
will take a more active role. Vadala
agreed to serve as an additional liaison
to the Sports Partnership Team between
USAB and the USOC. Vadala also stated
that the message was very clear from Mr.
Scherr that the problem will be
resolved.
B.
Agreements
1.
PPA Agreements (enclosed)
2.
Broadcast Rights Agreement (enclosed)
3. Trials Agreement
(enclosed)
V. Executive Director Search
Executive Director Search (Executive
Session begins at 10:40 a.m. and ends at
11 a.m.) (Robert Blaha and Buffy
conference call)
VI. Schedule of Events
A.
2007 Boxing Events Calendar
(Enclosed)
National Coach, Dan Campbell, stated
that the last of our selection
procedures for Olympic coaches and
additional officials were approved by
the USOC. Coach Campbell stated that he
is setting up a method to evaluate the
coaches. He will have an evaluation
form for each coach, which will be
reviewed by a task force committee and
the athlete representative. Coach
Campbell also stated that only 39
coaches qualified at a level 3 or 4. He
also informed the Board that we need to
update our coaches manual to reflect
what the qualifications consist of to
become a level 3 or level 4. Campbell
also reviewed his vision of athlete
development. He will be instructing the
athletes in biomechanics, good
nutrition, strength and coordination,
and the international style of boxing.
Virgets requested Coach Campbell prepare
and teach a clinic for coaches at the
Annual Meeting in November, teaching
coaches how to prepare athletes to
compete internationally.
1.
Qualifiers/Nationals
a.
Cincinnati April 2-6, 2007
b.
Cocoa Beach, Florida May 6-11
c.
Utah (34) May 20-25 Salt Lake City
d.
Nationals/Colorado Springs, June 2007
2.
Bend Oregon Agreement (Dual)
3.
Harvey, IL (Dual)
B.
Coaches (2006 list enclosed)
VII.
Television
A.
Reality Television Show
Stavros stated that he has a group in
Los Angeles willing to produce a reality
show about USAB; taking the show through
the Olympics. He continues a discussion
with the USOC which must have broadcast
rights once the event is an Olympic
Event.
B.
Global1NBC
Global1NBC presented a plan to broadcast
the Local Boxing Committees (LBCs)
events at the local level in web casts
and through local G1NBC T.V. franchise
because amateur sports are a local
hometown activity. Global1NBC is an IP
T.V. network, meaning they are Internet
protocol, and also own a cable
franchise. Discussions regarding a
partnership continue.
Virgets asked Malik how the Armed Forces
Championships held last night could be
viewed. Malik stated through
Globa1NBC’s website at this time. Malik
stated in April it could be viewed
through Global1NBC’s cable box, and the
cost of the box would be approximately
$12.95 a month through the local
affiliate. Malik explained that what he
would be marketing are the commercial
opportunities in that local area. Malik
explained that Global1NBC is privately
held and not publicly traded. They were
making their affiliates their
stockholders. Their website is
http://www.g1nbc.com/. Their
interest in broadcasting LBC Events, but
through the National Office.
C.
Altitude Cable Sports
Stavros stated that Altitude Sports will
be broadcasting USAB’s National
Championship and discussions with
Comcast are in progress. (Subsequently,
Comcast will be broadcasting the Eastern
Trials and may partner with Altitude to
offer national coverage of USA Boxing
Events.)
VIII.
Executive Director’s Report
A.
Membership and Communications
1.
Membership Promotional Package
(presentation)
Stavros presented a redesigned
membership package. This is a
promotional package supported by
television commercials which would be
introduced on USAB’s website for new
member registration. Upon joining, the
member would receive a membership
package to include a membership card,
welcome letter, a patch, a copy of the
USA Boxing magazine, and a customized
poster. He also reported USAB is
working with the USOC to design a 30
second commercial to begin to air as
soon as airtime becomes available.
Stavros stated that he proposes to
create a Friends of Boxing categories
for individuals who are interested in
supporting USA Boxing. He is proposing
a Gold, Silver and Bronze Program. The
revised membership package redesigns the
website, magazine, and creates a link to
USAB, the Foundation, Sponsors, etc.
2.
Northern/Central California Settlement
(enclosed)
3.
Pennsylvania Boxing Commission/Allegheny
An issue regarding the Allegheny LBC and
the Pennsylvania Athletic Boxing
Commission (PBAC) has surfaced over the
assignment and approval of officials.
This has been an ongoing situation with
the Alleghany LBC which is requesting
USAB’s support and involvement. USAB is
reviewing the rules for appointing
referees and will then contact the PBAC.
4.
Title Nine/Maine LBC
A female boxer has filed an action
against USA Boxing for alleging she was
not allowed an equal opportunity to
compete at the 2006 National
Championships. The case is being
reviewed by legal counsel.
B.
Agreements
1.
Nike (Enclosed)
2.
Everlast (Enclosed)
3. Miami Training Center
(Enclosed)
C.
Annual Meeting November 2007
Stavros informed the Board that he will
organize an Annual Meeting Task Force.
The Annual Meeting will be held in
conjunction with the Guns and Hoses
Event on November 10th in
Mesquite, Texas, and will be planned in
an educational format. It will include
a grant writing program, a seminar on
international coaching, and events
management training for taking the Guns
and Hoses program national.
MOTIONED/SECONDED/CARRIED (Franklin)
for Mesquite, Texas to be the site of
the Annual Meeting (Coulter)
seconded. Swavey in-charge.
IX.
A2P Update and Discussion
A2P dispute offered settlement. Details
of the settlement offer are by agreement
confidential.
MOTIONED/SECONDED/CARRIED (Franklin)
to accept the settlement
(Beasley) seconded.
X.
Financial Report
A.
2006 Financial Report – Pre-Audit
(Enclosed)
It is anticipated that USAB will close
2006 with an approximate $260,000
deficit due to the A2P monies withheld.
B.
2007 Budget Review
Chairman Virgets requested review of the
travel stipend policy with a clear
understanding that the LBC can only
receive funding when USAB has a balanced
budget, and has additional dollars to
offer. If USAB does not have funds,
travel stipends will be eliminated,
because it is believed this is a LBC
responsibility. Virgets suggested money
from the 2007 budget be reallocated with
the understanding that this support is
being phased out. In the meantime we
are also phasing in the Guns and Hoses
Program to help the LBCs raise funding
locally. Virgets requested Beasley and
Gleeson review the travel stipend
formula for the 2007 Nationals.
MOTIONED/SECONDED/CARRIED (Coulter)
Linda Gleeson and Jim
Beasley to create the formula for the
2007 Travel Stipends for the National
Championships.
C.
USOC Audit (Enclosed)
D.
Insurance Issues
1.
Liability
USAB’s insurance carrier already has
$600,000 letter–of-guarantee from the
Foundation for 2003 and 2004. The
insurance carrier is requesting an
additional $175,000 letter-of-credit, or
an additional $175,000 guarantee letter
from the Foundation in case of default.
The Foundation does not consider this an
emergency; therefore, the Foundation is
reluctant to sign a
letter-of-guarantee. Virgets is in
discussions with David Mair, an
insurance consultant, regarding
insurance alternatives. Virgets
questioned the benefit of USAB paying an
insurance premium because if the
insurance company pays out they might
cancel our insurance regardless.
Perhaps self-insurance is an option to
consider. Gleeson stated that USAB’s
insurance renewed in October 2006, and
it was renewed on the contingency of the
letter-of-guarantee. We need to either
obtain the guarantee letter from the
Foundation, or fund a $175,000
letter-of-credit. Gleeson stated that
another request should be made to the
Foundation for a letter-of-guarantee.
Virgets asked for a motion and request
to move forward on approaching the
Foundation for the guarantee letter.
Virgets will speak with Brad Smith of
the Foundation. (No Motion was
presented.)
2. Director’s and Officer’s
Insurance
USAB is trying to obtain the historical
data on 28 Directors and Officers (D&O)
claims. The D&O carrier requires that
every incident which may turn into a
claim be reported. If it does become a
claim, and USAB does not report the
incident, the claim will be denied.
USAB has had 28 claims in the recent
past of which four were considered
significant. David Mair, Insurance
Consultant, will provide a review.
E. Foundation Requests
(Enclosed)
Virgets stated that Andy Geiger will be
assigned the task of working with the
Foundation, seeking to have them more
involved in USAB issues. Gleeson will
review the Bylaws of the Foundation to
determine USAB’s role in approving the
amendments of the Foundations Bylaws.
USAB will provide a formal written
request to the Foundation for each of
the items to be funded. USA Boxing is
planning a balanced budget for 2007.
USAB is requesting support for the
membership package via a Foundation
request for $70,000.
MOTION/SECONDED/CARRIED (Coulter)
adopted as submitted to go forward to
the Foundation with the enclosed
requests (Swavey seconded).
F. Regional Foundation Grant
Requests (enclosed)
XI.
AIBA
A.
AIBA Grant Requests
USAB submitted a grant to hold the last
meeting of the AIBA Reform Committee in
Los Angeles, California in May, which
would have international media. USAB
was looking to shed a positive light on
the reform of AIBA, and to showcase the
USOC and USAB’s strong positive
relationship. However, the Reform
Committee decided to hold the last
meeting in Lausanne, Switzerland in
April. Virgets stated if the World
Championships become available again,
USAB would bid on the World
Championships. Virgets also stated that
USAB now has twelve members on AIBA
Committees.
XII.
Committee Reports
Stavros requested the committee
discussion be tabled. He will come
forward with an entire committee
structure at the next Board meeting.
The request was approved without
motion.
A. Working Committees/Task
Forces
1.
Women’s Task Force
2.
Local Boxing Committees Task Force
(LBCs)
3.
Guns and Hoses Task Force
4.
International Task Force
B.
New Committee Discussion
1.
Ethics (Board nomination requested
see Minutes)
2.
Compensation Committee
3. Judicial
4. Nominating and Governance
Committee 2 yr. term (See pages 18-24
of the Bylaws)
XIII. Next Meeting to be set in
May by conference call, or in person
attendance, depending on outstanding
issues.
XIV.
Adjournment
Respectfully submitted,
Debra A. Ketner, CPS/CAP
Executive Assistant
|